类比方法能否再证寒武纪生命大爆发?CAN CAMBRIAN ORGANISM EXPLOSION BE DEMONSTRATED FURTHER BY ANALOGY?
张宜
摘要(Abstract)：
用社会领域能够证明的思想大涌现事实,即中国先秦(春秋战国时期)和古希腊哲学思想在人类进入全新世特定历史阶段大涌现的史实,用类比方法再次证明了地质历史时期寒武纪生命大爆发存在性,从而加强了用归纳法得出的寒武纪生命大爆发论的可靠性。经过细致严谨的研究,寒武纪生命大爆发经历了一个较长的历史时期,这个历史时期相对于历史长河是较短的,给人以"突然出现"的假象,而思想大涌现同样经历了一个较长的历史时期(公元前约700年至公元前约200年)。在用类比方法论证寒武纪生命大爆发的基础上,进一步指出了生命大爆发论是对达尔文进化论的发展,而不是挑战。研究意义在于再次揭示了自然科学和社会科学之间的普遍联系,再次展示了用社会科学研究成果来解决自然科学领域问题这一思想和工作方法的可行性和价值。
关键词(KeyWords)： 类比推理;思想大涌现;生命大爆发;寒武纪
基金项目(Foundation): 国家重点基础研究发展规划项目“地史时期海陆生物多样性的演变”(2006CB806400);; 中国科学院知识创新工程重点方向项目(KZCX2-YW-105)
作者(Author): 张宜
参考文献(References)：
- ②Gishlick A.2003.Comments on the Discovery Institute’s“Analysis of the Evolutionin Biology Textbook”,submittedto the Texas Edu-cation Agency in connection with their July9,2003public hearing on textbook National Center for Science Education.
- 陈均远.2004.动物世界的黎明.南京:江苏科学技术出版社.1—366
- 陈均远,周桂琴,朱茂炎,叶贵玉.1996.澄江生物群———寒武纪大爆发的见证.台北:自然科学博物馆.1-222
- 陈良忠,罗惠麟,胡世学,尹济云,蒋志文,吴志亮,李峰,陈爱林.2002.云南东部早寒武世澄江动物群.昆明:云南科技出版社.1—199
- 迟维东.2005.逻辑方法与创新思维.北京:中央编译出版社.1—218
- 楚明锟.2004.逻辑学———正确思路与言语交际的基本工具.郑州:河南大学出版社.1—335
- 冯克正,傅庆升.1996.诸子百家大辞典.沈阳:辽宁人民出版社.1—1143
- 侯先光,杨·伯格斯琼,王海峰,冯向红,陈爱林.1999.澄江动物群—5.3亿年前的海洋动物.昆明:云南科学技术出版社.1—170
- 华洪,张录易,张子福,王静平.2000.晚震旦世高家山生物群化石新材料.古生物学报,39(3):381—390
- 江静波,陈俊民,陈如作,邝超源,徐利生,谭健明.1982.无脊椎动物学(第二版).北京:高等教育出版社.1—374
- 康德著,上海外国自然科学哲学著作编译组译.1972.宇宙发展史概论.上海:上海人民出版社.1—225
- 刘本培,全秋琦,冯庆来,赵锡文,周正国等.1996.地史学教程(第三版).北京:地质出版社.1—277
- 刘延勃,张弓长,马乾乐,张念丰.1983.哲学词典.长春:吉林人民出版社.1—746
- 罗素著,何兆武,李约瑟译.2003.西方哲学史—及其与从古代到现代的政治、社会情况的联系(上卷).北京:商务印书馆.1—590
- 麦吉尔F N著.《世界哲学宝库》编委会译.1991.世界哲学宝库———世界225篇哲学名著述评.北京:中国广播电视出版社.40—45
- 戎嘉余,樊隽轩,李国祥.2006a.华南史前海洋生物多样性的演变型式.见:戎嘉余,方宗杰,周忠和,詹仁斌,王向东,袁训来编.生物的起源、辐射与多样性演变———华夏化石记录的启示.北京:科学出版社.783—816
- 戎嘉余,方宗杰,周忠和,詹仁斌,王向东,袁训来.2006b.生物的起源、辐射与多样性演变———华夏化石记录的启示.北京:科学出版社.1—962
- 武汉大学,南京大学,北京师范大学.1983.普通动物学(第二版).北京:高等教育出版社.1—549
- Bergstr mJ.1993.The Cambrian radiation andits explanation.InHoch E&Brantsen A Keds.Deciphering the natural world andthe role of collections and Museums.Copenhagen:GeologiskMuseum.27—30
- Bergstr mJ.1997.Origin of high-rank groups of organisms.Paleon-tological Research,1(1):1—14
- Briggs D E G,Erwin D H&Collier F J.1994.The fossils of theBurgess shale.Washington and London:SmithsonianInstitutionPress.1—238
- Chi Wei-dong.2005.Logic methods and creative thoughts.Beijing:Central Compilation and Translation Press.1—218
- Chen Jun-yuan,Zhou Gui-qin,Zhu Mao-yan&Yeh Kuei-yu.1996.The Chengjiang Biota:a unique windowof the Cambrian explo-sion.Taichung:National Museumof Natural Science.1—222
- Chen Jun-yuan.2004.The dawn of ani mal world.Nanjing:JiangsuScience and Technology Press.1—366
- Chen Liang-zhong,Luo Hui-lin,Hu Shi-xue,Yin Ji-yun,Jiang Zhi-wen,Wu Zhi-liang,Li Feng&Chen Ai-lin.2002.Early Cam-brian Chengjiang fauna in eastern Yunnan China.KunmingYunnan Science and Technology Press.1—199
- Chu Ming-kun.2004.Logic:the basic tool of correct thought andspeech.Zhengzhou:Henan University Press.1—335
- Darwin C.1859.The origin of species.London:John Murry.1—502
- David S L.1972.International encyclopedia of the social sciences(5,6).New York:Macmillan Company and the Free Press.202
- Feng Ke-zheng&Fu Qing-sheng.1996.Adictionary of Chinese phi-losophers before Qin Dynasty.Shenyang:Liaoning People’sPublishing House.1—1143
- Hou Xian-guang,Bergstr mJ,Wang Hai-feng,Feng Xiang-hong&Chen Ai-lin.1999.The Chengjiangfauna:exceptionally well-pre-served ani mals from530million years ago.Kunming:YunnanScience and Technology Press.1—170
- Hua Hong,Zhang Lu-yi,Zhang Zi-fu&Wang Jing-ping.2000.Newfossil evidences fromlatest Neoproterozoic Gaojiashan bio-ta,south Shaanxi.Acta Palaeontologica Sinica,39(3):381—390
- Jiang Jing-bo,Chen Jun-min,Chen Ru-zuo,Kuang Chao-yuan,XuLi-sheng&Tan Jian-ming.1982.Invertebrate zoology(secondedition).Beijing:Higher Education Press.1—374
- Kant I.Translated by Shanghai Compilation and Translation Groupof Foreign Natural Science and Philosophy Works.1972.Allge-meine Naturgeschichte und Theorie des Hi mmels.Shanghai:Shanghai People’s Publishing House.1—142
- Liu Ben-pei,Quan Qiu-qi,Feng Qing-lai,Zhao Xi-wen,ZhouZheng-guoet al.1996.Acourse of historical Geology(third edi-tion).Beijing:Geological Publishing House.1—277
- Liu Yan-bo,Zhang Gong-chang,Ma Qian-le&Zhang Nian-feng.1983.A dictionary of philosophy,Changchun:Jilin People’sPublishing House.1—746
- Magill F N.Translated by The Compilation Committee of WorldPhilosophy.1991.World Philosophy Essay:Reviews of225Ma-jor Works.Beijing:China Radio and Television PublishingHouse.40—45
- Morris S C,Whittington HB,Briggs D E G,Hughes C P&BrutonD L.1982.Atlas of the Burgess Shale.England:Torr Press.1—31
- Morris S C.1986.The community structure of the Middle Cambrianphyllopod bed(Burgess Shale).Palaeontology,29(3):423—467
- Morris S C.1998.The crucible of creation-the Burgess shale and therise of ani mals.Oxford:Oxford University Press.1—242
- Rong Jia-yu,Fang Zhong-jie,Zhou Zhong-he,Zhan Ren-bin,WangXiang-dong&Yuan Xuan-lai.2006a.Originations,radiationsand biodiversity changes:evidences fromthe Chinese fossil re-cord.Beijing:Science Press.1—962
- Rongjia-yu,Fan Jun-xuan&Li Guo-xiang.2006b.Patterns of lat-est Proterozoic to early Mesozoic marine biodiversity changes insouth China.In:Rong Jia-yu,Fang Zhong-jie,Zhou Zhong-he,Zhan Ren-bin,Wang Xiang-dong&Yuan Xuan-lai eds.Origina-tions,radiations and biodiversity Changes:evidences from theChinese fossil record.Beijing:Science Press.785—816
- Russell B.Translated by He Zhao-wu&Li Yue-se.2003.A his-tory of western philosophy-and its connection with political andsocial circumstances fromthe earliest ti mes to the present day(1).Beijing:The Commercial Press.1—590
- Seng r A MC.2001.Is the present the key to the past or the pastthe keytothe present??James Huntton and AdamSmith ver-sus Abraham Gottlob Werner and Karl Marxininterpreting his-tory.Special Paper of Geology Society of America,335:1—51
- Shu De-gan,Morris S C,Han Jian,Chen Ling,Zhang Xing-liang,Zhang Zhi-fei,Liu Hu-qin,Li Yong&Liu Jia-ni.2001.Pri mi-tive deuterostomes from the Chengjiang Lagerstatte(LowerCambrian,China).Nature,414:419—424
- Walcott C D.1910.Abrupt appearance of the Cambrianfauna ontheNorth American continent.Cambrian Geology and PaleontologyII.Smithsonian Miscellaneous Collections,57:1—16
- Wuhan University,Nanjing University&Beijing Normal Universi-ty.1983.General zoology(second edition).Beijing:Higher Ed-ucation Press.1—549